Tuesday, November 17, 2026

This Thing of Darkness, by Harry Thompson

Cover of paperback edition of This Thing of Darkness by Harry Thompson, with illustration of the Beagle at sea
Earlier this year, I showed the teenage Lord of Chaos the film Master and Commander (2003), which proved a great success. Gary Gillatt then asked if I’d read this novel about the voyage of the Beagle and what became of its Captain FitzRoy. I’ve saved it as reward for completing work on my own book. What a treat it has been.

As a note tells us at the start, this epic, 750-page tale covers the period 1828 to 1865, largely based on real events and drawn from a wealth of primary sources detailed at the end. The first 150 pages involve FitzRoy’s first journey to Patagonia (prior to meeting Charles Darwin), where he decides to take four indigenous people with him back to England for some Christian education. In Part Two, he is assigned a naturalist for his return voyage, and we realise with horror it is not Darwin… 

We surely know at least some of what is to follow, but Thompson confounds our expectations. In part he does that by relaying how difficult things were — the chance by which people were assigned to now-famous roles, the limited confines of the Beagle, the dangers of the sea, the slow, dogged process of gathering evidence and making connections. It is at once fun and often funny adventure story and something more profound, about the philosophy of discovery, about intellectual hubris, about unintended consequence.

The author’s postscript tells us what became of the various characters involved, and where he simplified or reworked reality to suit the purposes of fiction. For example, we know only that Charles Darwin was impressed by his meeting with Juan Manuel de Rosas, president of the Buenos Aires Provence in what’s now Argentina, on 12 August 1833. Thompson invents their conversation, and tells us (on p. 740) that in doing so he drew from the self-justifying speeches of Tony Blair in the run up to the Gulf War. 

The point is that the adventure of the Beagle and the discoveries made on that voyage — Darwin’s deductions about earthquakes and evolution, FitzRoy’s about the weather — shape the world we live in now. We are therefore ahead of them as they stumble over the evidence and edge towards their revolutionary new ideas. Likewise, we know the tragedies to come: the massacres of indigenous people, the extinctions, the personal tragedies of many of these people.

Given our knowledge of events to come, many of the asides here are ironic, such as Darwin’s confident assertion:
“It is only a matter of time before such vested interests [in slavery] are overcome. Already the free people of colour in South Africa have legal equality with the whites.” (p. 263)
Of course, these people are all long dead anyway so it can’t exactly have a happy ending, but this book starts and ends with suicide, and what it really lays out is the tragedy of one extraordinary man beset by an ocean of troubles. It’s really good on the different, competing characters here; we warm to the friendship of Darwin and FitzRoy, so we really feel the pain of their split. The sudden deaths hit hard because we feel ourselves part of the crew.

A keen traveller, Thompson is fascinated by and empathetic towards the exotic places and peoples encountered here. But brilliantly, he depicts London as just as exotic, strange and dangerous — the visiting Patagonians take tea with the new King, but also venture into the slums. The effect is a bit like David Attenborough devoting the last episode of his natural history series Life on Earth (1979) to a study of humans, applying the same kind of gaze to ourselves as previous episodes applied to animals.

There’s some fantastic, vivid writing about the capital, such as this glimpse from 1865:
“The brand new clock tower housing Big Ben soared above the tumult, not yet soot-blackened like the other buildings round the square, but pale and stately; by common consent, the design of Britain’s newest landmark harked back to her medieval Gothic past, as if to ward of the encircling filth that poured forth from her factories, tramped across her fields and pastures, and laid siege to the remnants of her chivalric tradition” (p. 714).
I read that while working in Westminster this week, and was also brought up short by descriptions of my old stamping grounds in Sydenham and Crystal Palace — a sudden sense of connection to these real, long-dead people and the world we’ve shared.

No comments: